Brown lip liners have been a staple in our makeup routines for decades. MAC’s Lip Pencil in the shade Chestnut has been an icon since the ’90s. Today, the market offers tons of options, which makes it crucial to know what to look for when selecting the best brown lip liner for your needs.
When choosing a lip liner, it helps to consider factors like the undertone (because brown, rich brown, and deep brown each have their own unique vibe), the finish (matte is a classic, but satin also has its charm), and the staying power. No one wants a formula you need to keep reapplying throughout the day, so I’m here to help you choose correctly.
For your convenience, I’ve rounded up the best brown lip liners–all tried and tested. From waterproof options from Fenty Beauty to formulas that plump the lips like Kosas’s Hotline Hyaluronic Acid Contouring Lip Liner, there’s something for everyone.
This creamy, waterproof lip pencil from Ami Colé is all about defining your lips with zero fuss. Thanks to marula oil, it glides on easily. Shea butter then steps in to keep your lips nourished, while vitamin E adds a dose of moisture, making this liner a lip care hero.
Available at Sephora
Give a warm welcome to Fenty Beauty’s first-ever lip liner—the Trace’d Out Pencil Lip Liner. It’s pigmented, waterproof, and extra creamy, so it glides on like a dream, making it an incredibly comfortable option for filling and lining your lips.
Available at Fenty Beauty
The Huda Beauty Lip Contour 2.0 Automatic Matte Lip Pencil is a transfer-proof, waterproof, and long-lasting formula that’s ultra-pigmented and glides on like silk. It also features a retractable tip for easy application, so you never have to worry about sharpening it.
Available at Sephora
Thanks to its lip-lock technology and nourishing emollients, the Makeup by Mario Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil offers a comfortable, easy-to-apply experience. Plus, it comes with a dual-ended brush that effortlessly blends the formula for a flawless finish every time.
Available at Sephora
This ColourPop Lippie Pencil delivers a striking color payoff while staying super affordable at just $7. With hydrating ingredients that ensure your lips feel as good as they look, this pencil is a budget-friendly must-have for a flawless pout.
Available at Ulta Beauty
A true must-have in any makeup bag, this MAC Lip Pencil delivers intense color that stays put. It’s a go-to for defining lips to perfection.
Available at Mac Cosmerics